And I think Rhia totally got distracted by the mere thought of cakes, cookies, and pies. :::snaps fingers in Rhia's face::: FOCUS They're aren't even made yet!
You know, providing a detailed list of the baked goods available so completely did not help.
...mmm, pies.

...and I just realize that I have the same response to pie as I do to Adam Pascal. Hmm.
Poker, with candy to bet with? Maybe a movie night, if you can find something that everyone agrees with? Yard sales are always good, especially when you have multiple people contributing. I've done service auctions before for fundraisers, but I'm not sure what your community is like or how well that would work.